Our teams are looking into this as we speak and we hope to be able to resolve this issue as soon as possible. Utilitarianism john stuart mill batoche books faculty of social. The first has him thinking like an actutilitarian, that is, as one who does his thinking on a. Department of the arny field manual pm 27io, the law of land war. Utilitarianism states that the result of an act is the real measure of whether it is good or bad. It is part of the overarching ethical theory of consequentialism, which is the study of an individuals actions and the effect those actions had on the situation and others. One of the strengths of utilitarianism is its seeming objectivity. Dropping the atomic bombs on japan killed many people but the justification at the time was that it would save many more lives by ending the war quickly. Ethics and the war on terrorism t he purpose of this chapter is to explore some of the ethical issues associated with the war on terrorism that was declared following the events of 911. Pacifism conscientious objectors, mlk vietnam teleological some pacifists disagree in principle with the idea of war. If these rough connections hold, then weaknesses with those metaethical accounts most hospitable to deontology will weaken deontology as a normative theory of action.
Classical utilitarianism was never intended to be a comprehensive system of morality. After all, the human biological instinct tells us that more is always better. It is the only moral framework that can be used to justify military force or war. Shaw due to high volumes of traffic at this time we are experiencing some slowness on the site. Utilitarianism is based on the principle of utility. Pdf utilitarianism and the ethics of war, written by william h. He has also suggested using pacifism and just war theory as secondary rules or principles. Utilitarianism, in normative ethics, a tradition stemming from the late 18th and 19thcentury english philosophers and economists jeremy bentham and john stuart mill according to which an action is right if it tends to promote happiness and wrong if. Forthcoming in the handbook on the political economy of war, edited by chris coyne, elgar publishing. In other words, a country would not need a just war cause other than having the right. Utilitarianism, though, whatever we take the term to mean precisely, is the doctrine that in some sense, the ultimate moral standard is the promotion of the general good. Utilitarian view on terrorismwarfare as a part of the utilitarian thought process one searches for the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people which makes it easy to assume a utilitarian would be against all forms of war. University of british columbia and greqam walter bossert. Utilitarianism and the ethics of war crc press book.
What are the similarities and differences between kants. While rousseau posited a noble savage and marxian socialists have forecast human perfectibility, saint augustine and succeeding generations of catholic and protestant thinkers have asserted the principle of original sin. A helpful analogy for understanding a utilitarianism perspective on rights i think are traffic lights. Utilitarianism and war and peace flashcards quizlet. Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that determines right from wrong by focusing on outcomes. The utilitarian approach, also called utilitarianism, is essentially a moral principle that asserts that morally correct actions are those that provide the greatest volume of benefits over harms for the majority of people. We are reporting on a feminist tradition which we label anti war feminism. Utilitarianism and the ethics of war addresses the two basic ethical questions posed by war. According to act utilitarianism, if it produces more net utility or happiness to give money to famine relief, even though i had promised to payback a friend with that money, then i ought to give the money to the relief fund. Absolutism, utilitarianism, and moral military decision making.
A utilitarian argument against torture interrogation of. It was, in a sense, just a vulgar response to the grounding of morality on the rational self which was a popular topic for debat. I we can give an easy model of the value of an action. Discussion of this question has been dominated by realism, pacifism and just war theory. We show that two types of argumentsnamely a utilitarian argument based on parfits principle of group beneficence and a contractualist argumentcan ground an individual moral obligation to be vaccinated, in spite of the imperceptible contribution that any single vaccination makes to vaccine coverage rates. The study of the ethics of war is brimming with cases taken from the realist perspective, where war among states is neither right nor wrong and is viewed outside of morality all together, and. Pdf utilitarianism has a fairly bad reputation in military ethics, mainly. Establishing a normative and ethical approach toward countering terrorism may not seem to be salient to some in the face of the overwhelming events.
Furthermore, the tradition of just war that underlies much of the current regime of international law concerning wars between sovereign states may need to find. Just war utilitarianism approach in uncategorized on december 16, 2010 at 1. Other considerations critics of utilitarianism claim that it is an overly optimistic theory that fails to take into account motivations, focusing entirely on actions. While utilitarianism is currently a very popular ethical theory, there are some difficulties in relying on it as a sole method for moral decisionmaking. However, if one views just war theory in a freestanding normative context, then utilitarianism is a rival to it. Utilitarianism, act and rule internet encyclopedia of. Utilitarianism states that what makes an action right is that it produces the greatest amount of happiness not just your happiness, but others as well.
A reconsideration of the traditions moral foundation in light of the war against terrorism demonstrates that the most appropriate way to understand the just war tradition is from a rule utilitarian perspective rather than the more usual rightsbased, deontological perspective. There is hardly any similarity between utilitarianism and kantianism. Looking at the fifth chapter of mills utilitarianism in more depth, we can deduce many ideas that also relate to the war on iraq and whether it is a just or ethical war. Although different varieties of utilitarianism admit different characterizations, the basic idea behind all of them is to in some sense maximize utility, which is often defined in terms of wellbeing or related concepts. This theory emphasizes end over means, therefore it is a teleological or consequentialist ethical theory. Even if a states cause is just, for the war to be just the good which is at stake must outweigh the evils the war will cause to all sides.
Shaw presents his rather classical portrait of utilitarianism as. Utilitarianism in the workplace is associated with numerous advantages, including enhanced teamwork and productivity, positive public image and an improved society. Global poverty and the demands of morality toby ord global poverty is one of the most pressing issues of our time, yet many. First, the utilitarian calculation requires that we assign values to the benefits and harms resulting from our actions and compare them with the benefits and harms that might result from other. International law, multiple treaties,2 and every state officially. From this utilitarian analysis, i conclude that strong grounds exist to support intervening in the human germline using current technology. Utilitarianism and recourse to war utilitas cambridge core. We thank cepr for allowing us to organize a workshop on conflict in switzerland in the months before the deadline for this chapter.
The law of war has developed and will continue to develop driven by two radically different perspectives, that of the utilitarian or warrior and that of the humanitarian. A utilitarian approach is the greatest good for the greatest number. Wondering what utilitarianism is and how the aforementioned incident is an example of it. Before utilitarianism and iraq is examined more closely, the first factor to be considered in any ethical dispute about battle should be the just war theory. Is it wrong to kill someone from a utilitarian perspective. He uses utilitarianism to look at the costs and benefits of legalizing marijuana based on the results from legalizing alcohol. Utilitarianism and recourse to war volume 23 issue 4 william h. Rule utilitarianism act in accordance with those rules which, if generally followed, would provide the greatest general balance of pleasure over pain.
Utilitarianism i the most common form of consequentialism is utilitarianism i utilitarianism combines consequentialism with the claim that the only valuable consequence is pleasure, and the only disvaluable consequence is pain. From a utilitarian perspective, animals have rights so long as they may suffer. Delay in commencing such work will impose a utility cost, because the longer we wait until commencing the hggm revolution and moving towards a world of increased utility, the greater will be the quantity of. Utility, consequentialism, welfarism, morality, wellbeing. Utilitarianism in legalization of marijuana commtech ethics. First, the utilitarian calculation requires that we assign values to the benefits and harms resulting from our actions and compare them with the benefits and harms that might result from other actions. Some deontologists have thus argued that these connections need not hold and that a naturalistrealist metaethics can ground a deontological ethics moore 2004. The first, and shortest, portion of shaws book deals mainly with utilitarianism, the second with war. Shaw, utilitarianism and the ethics of war, routledge, 2016, 183pp. Utilitarianism and the theory of justice by charles blackorby, walter bossert and david donaldson august 1999 prepared as chapter 20 of the handbook of social choice and welfare k. Those people who ascribe to the theory of utilitarianism believe that in virtually all situations, the morally just route. Utilitarianism and war introduction war and violence have bedeviled humanity throughout recorded history.
Despite the enormous impact that war and the threat of war have had on human wellbeing, utilitarians have had surprisingly little to say about when, if ever, we may fight wars. This article takes some preliminary steps toward remedying this situation. Just war utilitarianism approach st georges philosophy. Utilitarianism is a family of consequentialist ethical theories that promotes actions that maximize happiness and wellbeing for the affected individuals.
In this new york times article, kirk johnson shares the discussion being had on the legalization of marijuana in accordance with the legalization of alcohol. Given the potential value of torture militarily, scholars and politicians have crafted various arguments to justify torture legally and morally. Three theories of war scholarspace university of hawaii. The theory of utilitarianism explained with examples. Introduction medicine is a costly science, but of greater concern to the health economist is that it is also a limitless art. Shaw concludes the advantage of using the utilitarianism approach to ethics on war is that it allows the theorist to sidestep many insoluble disputes that philosophers have when discussing ethics and war. We consider ourselves inheritors of this tradition and draw on it to formulate a position on weapons of mass destruction. Shaw hence argues that although just war theory on the surface. You have the green light that gives you a right of way, you have the red light that imposes a duty to stop.
I some utilitarians even allow for there to be quanti able units of pain and pleasure. I do not reach as far as statelevel issues, such as international covenants banning torture. Utilitarianism is teleological, so will look at the consequences of going to war to see if it is right. An ethical philosophy in which the happiness of the greatest number of people in the society is considered the greatest good. He references prohibition and talks about the outcome of the situation in that time period. A feminist ethical perspective on weapons of mass destruction. In a completely utilitarian perspective, choosing the five people is a better choice. To inquire how far the bad effects of this deficiency have been miti gated in practice, or to what extent the moral beliefs of. Wars have so many bad consequences that it is utilitarian to take a whole series of steps short of war before starting war. The bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki is a very prominent example of the philosophy of utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is the ethical notion that what is useful is good psy 533, 2017. From dershowitzs perspective, torture will inevitably occur, so a more realistic emphasis on accountability is important for reducing hypocrisy and minimizing the occurrence of torture dershowitz 2004.
How can concern with the general good dictate that respect for rights takes precedence over considerations of the general. Utilitarianism holds that the most ethical choice is the one that will produce the greatest good for the greatest number. William shaw has developed utilitarian war principles uwp to look at both these from a utilitarian perspective, as previously they have not been addressed. Utilitarian view on terrorismwarfare my ethical school. This analysis of war theories aims to extrapolate the war theory ideals from. A utilitarian would argue that sacrificing the lives of a few is right if it can save the lives of many. Deontological ethics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The first section of the chapter is largely descriptive as mill begins by saying that throughout history, one of. The promotion of the greatest happiness for the greatest number cannot justify some violation of an individuals welfare, if that individual has a right to the benefit in question. The challenge of utilitarianism and relativism to human rights. Utilitarianism and the ethics of war crc press book this book offers a detailed utilitarian analysis of the ethical issues involved in war. The most basic utilitarian critique of human rights lies in the assertion that resources are scarce in any society. Utilitarianism moral theory then, includes the important idea that when we calculate the utility of actions, laws, or policies, we must do so from an impartial perspective and not from a partialist perspective that favors ourselves, our friends, or others we especially care about.
889 65 625 262 280 1147 129 1207 825 862 1240 86 1083 65 441 188 1526 962 119 788 1533 94 1538 1386 35 1138 350 478 1207 1169 185 432 1205 881 337 433